The Wrong Arguments: let's focus on cause not symptoms.

In an era defined by urgent crises, we often find ourselves arguing over micro points rather than confronting the systemic issues that lie beneath. This tendency can be observed in two critical contexts: the global climate change protests and the ongoing debates surrounding the Treaty of Waitangi in Aotearoa New Zealand. In the first we focus on immediate concerns and the second illustrates a misguided spotlight on a history that can't change.

These valid and important arguements however, overlook much larger interconnected forces that, like Emperor Palpetine with his lightening fingers, drive both issues from the darkness.

Climate Change Protests: Enthusiasm Misguided

Take, for instance, the Students for Climate Change movement, a passionate collective of young activists demanding urgent action against climate change. Their protests are filled with energy and enthusiasm, drawing attention to the pressing need for policy changes, reduced emissions, and environmental sustainability. I love all they do and agree with every point they make.

Yet, while these demands are vital, they miss a critical point: the root cause of climate change is deeply embedded in neoliberal capitalism and the relentless pursuit of corporate profit.

Neoliberalism, with its emphasis on deregulation, privatisation, and consumerism, is the very engine driving environmental degradation. The fossil fuel industry, industrial agriculture, and unsustainable consumption patterns thrive under a capitalist system that prioritises short-term gains over long-term sustainability. In focusing on immediate policy reforms and demanding change from political leaders, activists can inadvertently divert attention from the broader economic structures that perpetuate environmental destruction.

Instead of channeling passions toward reforming bottom of the cliff policies, the Students for Climate Change movement could direct their enthusiasm at dismantling the very economic system that fuels climate chaos. Advocating for systemic changes—such as transitioning to a circular economy, prioritising social equity, and challenging corporate greed—could pave the way for genuine progress. However, the allure of protesting visible injustices often overshadows the harder conversations about the fundamental economic structures that require change.

The Treaty of Waitangi: A Historical Focus in a Diverse Future

In Aotearoa, the debate surrounding the Treaty of Waitangi is a deep rooted challenging conversation. It also exemplifies our tendency to fixate on the past rather than envisioning a collaborative future. While it is crucial to acknowledge the historical injustices faced by Māori and the unacceptable racism that persists, the ongoing focus on the Treaty often overlooks the complex reality of contemporary Aotearoa, a nation enriched by over 200 ethnicities and cultures.

As we near 2025, it is essential to recognise that many people in Aotearoa, regardless of their ethnic background, are grappling with significant financial challenges. The high cost of living, housing shortages, and inadequate access to healthcare affect a broad spectrum of the population. Yet, discussions about the Treaty frequently become mired in historical grievances, diverting attention from the pressing socioeconomic issues that touch everyone.

Amid these discussions, white wealthy populist politicians frequently engage in dog whistle politics, invoking race arguments that suggest we are all the same and should be treated as such. This oversimplification dismisses the rich diversity of identities that exist within our society.

Understanding and celebrating these identities is essential for fostering genuine community and inclusivity. Instead of recognising the unique challenges and contributions of various groups, this approach serves to unify narratives that benefit those in power while stifling meaningful dialogue.

This focus suits those who benefit from the current economic structures, allowing them to deflect criticism while the public remains engaged in debates that, while important, do not address the underlying causes of social disadvantage. Neoliberal capitalism has created a reality where economic disparities are widespread, yet public discourse often remains fixated on historical narratives instead of collaborating to find solutions that uplift all communities.

A Call for Systemic Change

Both climate change activism and the Treaty of Waitangi discussions highlight a crucial truth: we tend to argue the wrong points, concentrating on symptoms rather than tackling the systemic issues that fuel them. Neoliberal capitalism is not just a theoretical construct; it shapes our everyday lives and exacerbates environmental and social inequities.

As we move forward, it is imperative that we broaden our focus. Rather than solely protesting against specific policies or historical injustices, we should be advocating for transformative changes to the systems that govern our lives. By challenging the economic structures that perpetuate inequality and environmental degradation, we can create a future that is equitable, sustainable, and inclusive for all.

The time has come for a collective awakening—an understanding that our arguments must evolve from micro points to a broader critique of the systems that define our world. Only then can we hope to forge a path toward meaningful change, benefiting not just a select few but all members of society.

Once again, thanks for your eyes and your minds.

Until next time,

Gordy